The 3 Paradoxes of AI Coding Tools
- AI writes the code, but developers are still responsible for reviewing it.
- Verifying code generated without context is harder than writing it yourself.
- AI productivity permanently raises management’s expectations.
Writing Code Was the Easy Part Anyway
Developer Matthew Hansen made an interesting point.[BlunderGoat] Typing code is the easy part. The real challenge is research, understanding context, and validating assumptions.
When AI takes over code generation, all that’s left are the hard parts. You also lose the contextual understanding you gain from writing it yourself.
The Pitfalls of “Vibe Coding”
There’s a case where an AI agent deleted 400 lines while adding tests.[BlunderGoat] It’s fine for prototypes, but dangerous in production.
Hansen described AI as having “senior technical skills with junior-level trustworthiness.” It writes code well but doesn’t understand the organizational context.
The Vicious Cycle Created by the Productivity Illusion
If you show high productivity with AI, management will take that as the new standard.[BlunderGoat] This creates a vicious cycle where exhausted engineers skip tests.
There are effective use cases. Use AI for bug investigation, but have humans provide context and validation. AI handles the analysis, humans make the judgments.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: Will AI coding tools replace developers?
A: Unlikely, at least for now. AI excels at code generation, but requirements analysis and architecture decisions are still human domains. Developers are also responsible for verifying and taking ownership of AI-generated code.
Q: What is “vibe coding”?
A: It’s a casual approach where you give AI vague instructions and let it generate code. Useful for prototypes, but carries the risk of unexpected changes in production.
Q: How can I use AI coding tools effectively?
A: The key is to use AI for research and analysis, but provide context and validate the results. Maintain your judgment capabilities instead of completely outsourcing generation.
If you found this helpful, please subscribe to AI Digester.
References
- AI Makes the Easy Part Easier and the Hard Part Harder – BlunderGoat (2026-01-31)
- The Changing Role of Developers in the AI Era – Stack Overflow Blog (2023-12-04)
- Coding Assistants and the Future of Software Development – O’Reilly (2024-06-15)